Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Material relating to the philately of the reign of Queen Victoria.
Post Reply
Unclepyro
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Apr 09, 2024 11:16 am

Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Unclepyro »

Hi again.
This has had me tied in knots for weeks:
The apparently simple answer that this is an AS32 3rd repair 2nd state has had me doubting.
My example has some unmentioned additions and suggests that this is a later unrecorded repair:
My stamp has a SSWX, thinner baselines, A Horizontal guide line in the SE Box across the top of the "A" and the bottom right of the "A" is recut. None of these are apparent in the 2nd state.
I've even considered it as a 1b with a repositioned "L"
And also a 27 but that has no evidence of the NNE being repaired.
The answer is probably simple but evades me, I hope you experts out there can help me
Cheeers
Rich.
Attachments
My Stamp
My Stamp
Sg8 Batch4 LA  pl xx.crop b.JPG
SSW extends, Framelines thinner, Horizontal guideline through top of "A" and bottom "A" recut.
SSW extends, Framelines thinner, Horizontal guideline through top of "A" and bottom "A" recut.
Plate 5 State 1
Plate 5 State 1
Plate 5 State 2
Plate 5 State 2
User avatar
Galveston
Posts: 47
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2022 10:05 pm
Location: Louisiana Gulf South - USA

Re: Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Galveston »

Curious , did you by chance look at the Repairs link on the homepage? It has a lot of info for plate 5 I think.
Keep On Stamping
Unclepyro
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Apr 09, 2024 11:16 am

Re: Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Unclepyro »

Hi Galveston, yeah I did.
That's what's caused my confusion.
Cheeeers
User avatar
Galveston
Posts: 47
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2022 10:05 pm
Location: Louisiana Gulf South - USA

Re: Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Galveston »

I saw that you were new and was curious if you’d seen that feature. It took me awhile before I had…. I’d be more than happy to take a look, but I’m very much the beginner. Hopefully one of the experts will add a bit.
Keep On Stamping
User avatar
Galveston
Posts: 47
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2022 10:05 pm
Location: Louisiana Gulf South - USA

Re: Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Galveston »

So I took a look and it a stumper to me and I understand your dilemma. Im no expert as stated and do not see a Hgl SE or the re-cut ' A ' I did gravitate to plate 27 too. I would think the ' L ' tilted W would stand out somewhere but did not see it or the break in the SE square. Sorry - one for the experts. I did measure 4+ 3+ 4 13- and with a +/- 4 returned
Screenshot 2024-05-28 at 21.30.27.png

Curious too! Sorry not more help.
Keep On Stamping
Unclepyro
Posts: 6
Joined: Tue Apr 09, 2024 11:16 am

Re: Sg7 Plate 5 LA 3rd. Repair... Or is it ????

Post by Unclepyro »

Cheers for you interest Galveston. I've been on this one for weeks and all I do is jump between Plate 5, 1b and 27.
The HGl in the SE is very faint and runs across the top of "A" the recut A is just my observation that right foot looks to have some additional markings compared to the three plates. and that little extension of the SW frame seems like a later addition.
Thanks again:-)
Post Reply